Bookstagram vs. BookTok: Which One Actually Sells More Books?

We hope you enjoy reading this post!
If you’re like us and love to read, then click here to score tons of free and discounted ebooks.

In the ever-evolving world of book marketing, social media has become one of the most powerful tools for authors and publishers. Two platforms, in particular, have emerged as major players in the bookish community: Bookstagram (Instagram’s book-loving corner) and BookTok (TikTok’s viral book space). Both have created trends, catapulted books onto bestseller lists, and changed the way readers discover their next favorite read. But when it comes to actual book sales, which platform has the bigger impact?

Bookstagram is known for its beautifully curated aesthetic, in-depth reviews, and loyal reader communities. BookTok, on the other hand, thrives on fast-paced, emotionally charged recommendations that have sent books flying off shelves overnight. Each platform offers unique advantages, but their effectiveness in driving sales can differ based on genre, audience, and marketing strategies.

So which one should authors and publishers invest their time in? Let’s break down the strengths and weaknesses of both platforms, analyze their influence on book sales, and help you decide where to focus your efforts for the best results.

Understanding Bookstagram

What is Bookstagram?

Bookstagram is the book-loving community on Instagram, where readers, authors, and publishers come together to share their passion for books through visually appealing content. The term “Bookstagram” stems from the combination of “book” and “Instagram,” highlighting the platform’s focus on aesthetic presentation. Users post carefully curated photos of books, engaging captions, and thoughtful reviews, creating a visually rich experience for fellow book lovers.

How Authors and Publishers Use It

Bookstagram has become a key tool for book marketing, offering a space where authors and publishers can showcase their books in a way that feels personal and organic. Some of the most common strategies include:

• Aesthetic Book Photos: Beautifully staged images featuring books alongside props like candles, coffee, and cozy settings to create an inviting atmosphere.
• Reels and Stories: Short-form videos, unboxings, behind-the-scenes content, and quick book reviews to boost engagement.
• Hashtag Trends: Popular hashtags like #Bookstagram, #Bookstagrammer, and #CurrentlyReading help increase visibility.
• Collaborations with Influencers: Publishers and indie authors partner with Bookstagrammers to feature their books in exchange for free copies or promotional deals.
• Engaging Captions & Reviews: Thoughtful and in-depth reviews encourage discussion and community interaction.

Strengths of Bookstagram

• Beautiful Visuals: The platform is highly aesthetic, making books more appealing and engaging for potential readers.
• Long-Term Engagement: Unlike fast-paced platforms, Instagram posts remain discoverable for longer, especially with proper hashtags and engagement.
• Curated Content: Users create polished and thoughtful book-related content, making it an ideal platform for building a brand and long-term relationships with readers.

Weaknesses of Bookstagram

• Slower Reach: Unlike TikTok, where content can go viral overnight, Bookstagram relies on consistent engagement and slow organic growth.
• Algorithm Limitations: Instagram’s algorithm prioritizes engagement, meaning posts can get buried unless they receive immediate interaction.
• Less Virality: While books can gain traction through dedicated book influencers, the platform doesn’t have the same explosive, trend-driven reach as BookTok.

Bookstagram remains a strong marketing tool for authors who want to build a long-term audience, establish a brand, and engage deeply with dedicated readers. However, it may not always deliver immediate sales spikes compared to its fast-moving counterpart, BookTok.

Understanding BookTok

What is BookTok?

BookTok is the book-centric community on TikTok, where readers, authors, and influencers share book recommendations, reviews, and reactions through short-form video content. Unlike the curated aesthetics of Bookstagram, BookTok thrives on raw, emotional, and often fast-paced content that connects instantly with audiences. This community has played a major role in reviving backlist titles, catapulting lesser-known authors into the mainstream, and shaping bestseller lists through viral trends.

How Books Go Viral on BookTok

The power of BookTok lies in its ability to make books go viral in an instant. Here’s how it happens:

• Short-Form Videos: Engaging clips, often under 60 seconds, featuring dramatic reactions, recommendations, and aesthetic book montages.
• Trending Sounds: Many BookTok videos pair emotional or relatable audio clips with book content, making posts more engaging and shareable.
• Emotional Reactions: Passionate videos—whether it’s crying over a heartbreaking twist or gasping at a plot twist—drive engagement and book sales.
• Hashtag Trends: Popular hashtags like #BookTok, #BookTokMadeMeBuyIt, and #MustRead help boost visibility.
• Chain Reactions: Once a book gains momentum, more creators start posting about it, pushing it further into the algorithm and onto readers’ bookshelves.

Strengths of BookTok

• Massive Reach: TikTok’s algorithm allows content to reach a huge audience quickly, even without a large following.
• Fast-Paced Trends: Books can become bestsellers overnight if they gain traction within the community.
• Organic Discovery: Unlike traditional marketing, BookTok’s power comes from genuine reader recommendations, making it highly influential in driving sales.

Weaknesses of BookTok

• Short Content Lifespan: Viral videos can lose traction quickly, meaning a book’s hype may fade as fast as it started.
• Unpredictable Virality: There’s no formula for making a book trend—success is often random and dependent on timing and engagement.
• Genre Favoritism: Romance, fantasy, and emotionally intense books perform exceptionally well, while other genres (like literary fiction or non-fiction) struggle to gain the same traction.

BookTok’s strength lies in its ability to create instant buzz, making it a game-changer for authors looking for explosive sales spikes. However, the platform’s unpredictable nature means that while some books experience overnight success, others may struggle to gain visibility at all.

The Sales Impact: Which Platform Moves More Books?

Case Studies & Examples: Books That Blew Up on BookTok vs. Bookstagram

Both platforms have contributed to book sales, but BookTok has produced some of the most dramatic success stories in recent years. A few key examples include:

• BookTok Success Stories:

  • It Ends With Us by Colleen Hoover – This book, originally published in 2016, saw an explosive resurgence thanks to emotional BookTok reactions, making Hoover one of the top-selling authors worldwide.
  • The Song of Achilles by Madeline Miller – A viral trend featuring readers sobbing over the book’s ending led to a massive spike in sales years after its initial release.
  • Lightlark by Alex Aster – The author leveraged BookTok to promote the book even before publication, leading to a bidding war among publishers and a bestseller debut.

• Bookstagram Success Stories:

  • The Night Circus by Erin Morgenstern – This visually stunning novel has maintained steady popularity on Bookstagram thanks to its dreamy aesthetic, making it a staple in “bookshelf tour” and “book flat-lay” posts.
  • The Starless Sea by Erin Morgenstern – Another book that thrives on Bookstagram’s aesthetic appeal, with its intricate cover and rich storytelling inspiring long-term engagement.
  • Fourth Wing by Rebecca Yarros – This book had crossover success, gaining traction on both Bookstagram and BookTok, showing how a strong visual presence and viral reactions can combine for maximum impact.

Data & Reports: How BookTok and Bookstagram Influence Sales

Recent publishing industry reports highlight that BookTok has driven more direct sales than Bookstagram due to its viral nature. Some key statistics:

• According to a 2023 NPD BookScan report, books that trended on BookTok saw a 50–200% increase in sales, often pushing them onto bestseller lists.
• TikTok reported that the hashtag #BookTok had over 200 billion views, indicating its massive influence in book discovery.
• Publishers have noted that BookTok has contributed to steady backlist sales, helping older books gain new life.
• While Bookstagram is a strong branding tool, Instagram’s engagement rates (especially for organic posts) are lower than TikTok’s, making it less effective at driving immediate purchases.

Publisher & Author Insights

Industry professionals recognize that BookTok is a dominant sales driver, but Bookstagram still plays an important role in long-term author branding.

• Publishers’ View: Many publishers now actively scout for BookTok trends to inform their acquisitions, and some even encourage authors to create TikTok content.
• Authors’ Experience: Indie authors report that viral BookTok videos can generate thousands of sales in a matter of days, while Bookstagram helps maintain a loyal, engaged audience over time.
• Booksellers’ Perspective: BookTok displays in major bookstores like Barnes & Noble and Target have further cemented its influence in driving in-store purchases.

Which Platform is Better for Different Authors?

Traditional vs. Indie Authors

• Traditional Authors: Benefit from both platforms, as publishers often handle Bookstagram collaborations while BookTok can boost organic reach.
• Indie Authors: BookTok is often more accessible, allowing self-published authors to gain visibility without relying on publisher-backed marketing. However, those who build a strong Bookstagram presence can develop a loyal reader base that sustains long-term sales.

Genre Considerations

• BookTok Favorites: Romance, fantasy, YA, thrillers, and emotionally intense books tend to perform best. If a book has a shocking twist, a slow-burn romance, or an emotional punch, it’s more likely to gain traction.
• Bookstagram’s Strengths: Literary fiction, historical fiction, and non-fiction often find a more consistent audience on Bookstagram, where readers appreciate in-depth reviews and discussions.

• Overlapping Genres: Some books, like Fourth Wing or The House in the Cerulean Sea, succeed on both platforms, showing that a well-targeted strategy can amplify reach.

Marketing Strategies: How to Leverage Each Platform for Maximum Impact

• For BookTok:

  • Create engaging videos using trending sounds and captions.
  • Share emotional reactions, aesthetic book clips, and fast-paced recommendations.
  • Engage with trends like “Books that made me cry” or “If you liked X, read Y.”
  • Interact with the community through comments, duets, and collaborations.

• For Bookstagram:

  • Post high-quality book photos with engaging captions and hashtags.
  • Use Reels to boost discoverability.
  • Collaborate with Bookstagram influencers for features and reviews.
  • Engage in themed challenges like “#MonthlyWrapUp” or “#BookShelfTour.”

The Future of Book Marketing on Social Media

Will BookTok Continue Dominating, or Will Bookstagram Evolve?

While BookTok is currently the dominant force in book marketing, Instagram is adapting by incorporating more short-form video content through Reels. This shift could make Bookstagram more competitive in the future. However, TikTok’s ability to rapidly push books into mainstream success still gives it an edge.

Emerging Trends and New Platforms to Watch

• YouTube Shorts: Some book influencers are expanding onto YouTube Shorts for a blend of BookTok-style engagement with YouTube’s long-term discoverability.
• Threads & BlueSky: As social media platforms evolve, new communities could emerge that offer fresh ways to market books.
• AI & Personalization: Future trends may include AI-driven recommendations and personalized book marketing based on user behavior.

Conclusion

Summary of Findings: BookTok vs. Bookstagram

• BookTok excels at generating rapid sales spikes, especially for emotionally engaging or dramatic books. Its viral nature makes it ideal for authors looking for explosive growth.
• Bookstagram is a strong long-term branding tool, fostering steady engagement and reader loyalty. While it doesn’t have the same virality, it provides a more curated and aesthetic marketing approach.

Final Thoughts: Where Should Authors Focus?

• For short-term book sales and viral potential, prioritize BookTok.
• For long-term engagement and brand building, invest in Bookstagram.
• For the best results, use both platforms strategically.

Ultimately, the best platform depends on an author’s genre, marketing goals, and ability to engage with the community. In an ideal scenario, leveraging both BookTok’s virality and Bookstagram’s steady engagement can create a powerful book marketing strategy that maximizes reach and sales.

Where have you see success as an author? Be sure to let us know in the comments below!