If you’re like us and love to read, then click here to score tons of free and discounted ebooks.
Historical fiction holds a unique place in literature. It allows us to step into another time, immersing ourselves in lives shaped by cultures, struggles, and events that feel both distant and familiar. When done well, historical fiction bridges the past and present, offering timeless stories that resonate with modern readers while staying true to history’s complexity. But what exactly makes a historical fiction novel truly great? Let’s take a look at the key elements that elevate the genre.
1. Authentic Historical Setting
At the heart of every historical fiction novel lies its setting. The time period must feel authentic—whether it’s ancient Rome, medieval Japan, or 1920s Harlem. That doesn’t mean cramming the story with endless facts, but rather weaving in just enough detail to ground the reader. Clothing, architecture, language patterns, and cultural norms should emerge naturally through the narrative. A great historical setting feels lived-in, not like a museum exhibit.
Examples:
Hilary Mantel’s Wolf Hall perfectly captures Tudor England through small details—the smell of rushes on floors, the weight of heavy fabrics, the precarious nature of candlelight. Rather than lengthy descriptions of Henry VIII’s court, Mantel shows us Thomas Cromwell navigating cramped, cold rooms where privacy doesn’t exist and every conversation might be overheard.
Colson Whitehead’s The Underground Railroad transforms 1850s America through both historically accurate details (the brutal realities of plantation life) and imaginative elements (a literal underground railroad), creating a setting that feels both authentic and mythic.
2. Thorough but Invisible Research
The best historical fiction is built on research, but it never reads like a textbook. Readers want the richness of history without feeling lectured. Authors achieve this balance by focusing on small, specific details—a meal, a gesture, or a phrase of dialogue—that bring a moment to life. When the research is seamlessly integrated, the reader feels transported without noticing the scaffolding behind the story.
Examples:
Anthony Doerr’s All the Light We Cannot See demonstrates this beautifully. His depiction of 1940s Saint-Malo comes through specific details—the way Marie-Laure navigates by counting steps and feeling textures, or how Werner’s radio expertise reflects actual German military technology—without ever feeling like a history lesson.
Madeline Miller’s Circe weaves in extensive knowledge of Greek mythology and ancient Mediterranean life through Circe’s daily routines of herb-gatheri
3. Complex, Relatable Characters
While history is the backdrop, the characters are the heart of the story. Great historical fiction doesn’t just show us what people did in the past, but how they felt. Characters should grapple with universal human dilemmas—love, ambition, fear, loyalty—even as those struggles are shaped by their era’s unique challenges. Relatable characters make the past feel immediate and alive.
Examples:
Tara Westover’s Educated (though memoir, it reads like historical fiction) shows how universal desires for knowledge and belonging clash with rigid family beliefs in 1990s rural Idaho.
Min Jin Lee’s Pachinko spans generations of a Korean family, showing how characters like Sunja face timeless dilemmas of survival, dignity, and protecting family while navigating the specific challenges of Japanese occupation and discrimination.
4. Conflict that Reflects the Era
Every novel needs conflict, but in historical fiction, that conflict should reflect the realities of the time period. This might mean navigating class systems, surviving war, confronting social injustices, or adapting to technological change. A great story highlights how individuals are caught between personal desires and the forces of history, allowing readers to see both the sweep of events and the intimacy of lived experience.
Examples:
Margaret Atwood’s Alias Grace centers on Grace Marks navigating 1840s Canadian society where women had no legal rights and were defined entirely by their relationships to men. The central mystery is inseparable from the era’s attitudes toward female psychology and criminality.
Yaa Gyasi’s Homegoing traces how the legacy of slavery creates different but connected conflicts for characters across centuries—from Effia navigating the Gold Coast slave trade to Marcus confronting mass incarceration in modern Harlem.
5. Balance Between Accuracy and Storytelling
Historical accuracy matters—but so does pacing, drama, and emotional truth. Too much emphasis on fact-checking can stall the narrative, while too much artistic liberty risks breaking trust with the reader. The sweet spot lies in honoring the spirit of the era while still delivering a compelling, page-turning story. Authors often bend small details in service of character and theme, but the overall framework of the time period must remain recognizable and respectful.
Examples:
Khaled Hosseini’s The Kite Runner uses 1970s-2000s Afghanistan to explore universal themes of guilt, redemption, and father-son relationships that speak directly to contemporary readers regardless of their familiarity with Afghan history.
Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie’s Half of a Yellow Sun examines the 1960s Biafran War through themes of love, loyalty, and survival that illuminate current conflicts and human resilience across cultures.
6. Themes That Resonate Across Time
The best historical fiction doesn’t just recount what happened long ago—it speaks to us now. Themes of resilience, power, injustice, love, and hope remind readers that although centuries may separate us from the characters, the human experience is shared. These timeless themes give historical fiction its enduring power.
Examples:
Khaled Hosseini’s The Kite Runner uses 1970s-2000s Afghanistan to explore universal themes of guilt, redemption, and father-son relationships that speak directly to contemporary readers regardless of their familiarity with Afghan history.
Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie’s Half of a Yellow Sun examines the 1960s Biafran War through themes of love, loyalty, and survival that illuminate current conflicts and human resilience across cultures.
7. Evocative Writing Style
Finally, great historical fiction requires prose that transports. The writing should evoke the textures, sounds, and rhythms of the past without slipping into imitation or archaic stiffness. Vivid descriptions and sensory detail immerse readers, while carefully chosen dialogue captures the flavor of the time without becoming incomprehensible.
Examples:
Pat Barker’s The Silence of the Girls uses contemporary prose rhythm while capturing the epic scope of the Trojan War, making ancient events feel immediate without resorting to faux-archaic language.
Hamnet by Maggie O’Farrell evokes Shakespeare’s era through sensory details—the texture of wool, the smell of herbs, the sounds of Elizabethan streets—while maintaining lyrical, accessible modern prose.
A Last Word
A great historical fiction novel is a dance between history and imagination. It requires a deep respect for the past, an understanding of timeless human struggles, and a gift for storytelling that sweeps readers away. When all these elements align, historical fiction doesn’t just tell us what the past was like—it lets us live it.
Comments