If you’re like us and love to read, then click here to score tons of free and discounted ebooks.
Writing horror that truly scares people isn’t just about blood, monsters, or loud noises. It’s about unease. Dread. That moment when the reader lowers the book and glances around the dark room, suddenly unsure of what’s in the shadows.
If you’re an author aiming to write horror that lingers—something readers feel in their bones—this guide is for you. Let’s break down what really makes horror scary, and how to wield those elements effectively.
1. Start with Fear, Not Monsters
The scariest horror doesn’t begin with creatures. It begins with the feeling of something being wrong.
Start by identifying a core fear: isolation, helplessness, being watched, losing control, the unknown, betrayal, death, madness. Real horror taps into these primal fears and then builds a situation around them.
Example: In The Shining, the real horror isn’t the haunted hotel—it’s Jack’s descent into madness and the helplessness of his family trapped with him.
2. Create Tension, Not Just Surprises
Jump scares may work in film, but on the page, suspense is king. Dread builds slowly. Your job is to stretch the tension like a wire—tight, taut, humming with the possibility of snapping.
Tips:
- Let the reader know something is wrong before the character does.
- Use pacing to your advantage: long, quiet moments interrupted by small, subtle wrongness.
- Break the pattern. Readers feel safest when they can predict. Strip that comfort away.
The hallway was empty. Still, she couldn’t shake the feeling that something had been watching her just before she turned the light on.
3. Leverage the Unknown
Humans fear what they don’t understand. So don’t explain everything.
Resist the urge to over-explain your ghost, entity, or evil force. Leave room for imagination. What readers imagine will almost always be worse than anything you describe.
Tip: When you reveal something horrific, do it in layers. Let the reader question what they’re seeing or reading. The mind will fill in the gaps—often with something much worse.
4. Write Characters That Readers Care About
If readers don’t care who lives or dies, your horror falls flat. The more invested they are, the more terrifying it is when something threatens those characters.
Give your characters:
- Flaws that make them real
- Personal stakes in the plot
- Secrets they’re afraid to confront
Don’t just write someone being chased—write someone being chased who has a reason to survive. Read more here about how to create round characters that people will care about.
5. Use Setting as a Character
Great horror lives in its setting. It presses in. It isolates. It has personality.
Your haunted house, decrepit town, or endless woods should influence mood and action. The setting isn’t just where the horror happens. It helps create it.
Examples:
- A fog that hides something moving just out of sight.
- A mirror that doesn’t quite reflect the right thing.
- A locked room that shouldn’t be cold, but is.
6. Let the Horror Escalate Intelligently
Effective horror builds. Start small: misplaced items, a wrong reflection, a sound with no source. Then gradually increase the danger, the strangeness, the disorientation.
Avoid jumping straight to possession, bloodbaths, or end-of-the-world stakes. Horror is more powerful when it spirals. By the time the worst hits, your reader should be so tangled in the web that they can’t look away.
7. Know the Difference Between Horror and Shock
Shock is short-term. Horror lingers.
You might write a shocking death scene—but if there’s no emotional or thematic weight, it won’t stick. True horror stays with the reader because it speaks to something deeper: mortality, trauma, existential dread, human nature.
Ask yourself: What does this horror mean?
The Power of Horror
Scary stories aren’t just about scaring people. They’re about giving readers a safe way to explore what they’re afraid of—and maybe even what they don’t realize they’re afraid of. That’s the real power of horror.
So when you write, don’t just ask, “What would be scary here?”
Ask:
- What’s wrong here?
- What would make the reader feel unsafe?
- What truth is hiding underneath the fear?
And remember: A monster can be terrifying. But a quiet knock at the door, in a place no one should be, at a time no one should come—that’s horror that haunts.
Want more horror writing tips?
- Drop your questions below or share your favorite horror novels that got under your skin. Let’s talk fear.
Comments